A Heavenly Deal for Pujols Could Be Hell for Angels

Albert Pujols is now an Angel with a heavenly salary of $250 million over 10 years. At age 31, he is considered by many to be baseball’s best player.

Albert Pujols Stats

A statistical analysis shows Pujols was worth 89.1 more wins than a generic first baseman during his first 11 seasons with St. Louis – the 7th highest Wins Against Replacement (WAR) total in baseball history for players through age 31. Take a look at how he stacks up against other baseball legends in the WAR Department:

Ty Cobb           112.5
Mickey Mantle     101.1
Rogers Hornsby    100.9
Babe Ruth          96.8
Hank Aaron         90.2
Alex Rodriguez    89.7
ALBERT PUJOLS      89.1
Lou Gehrig         86.9
Willie Mays        86.9
Mel Ott            86.8

But if history is our guide, El Hombre won't be nearly as productive
over the next 10 years.Take a look at how the same baseball greats
fared after age 32, measured in Wins Above Replacement:

Babe Ruth          75.2
Willie Mays        67.8
Hank Aaron         51.4
Ty Cobb            46.9
Lou Gehrig         31.5
Rogers Hornsby     26.9
Mel Ott            22.5
Mickey Mantle      19.1
Alex Rodriguez     15.2
ALBERT PUJOLS      ????

In other words, King Albert may give the Angels a great return on investment for another
5 years, but by age 37 his body will start to break down and he'll become a very expensive
Designated Hitter (good thing for Albert he's in the American League).

Some players defy the aging process, like Hank Aaron, who hit 47 homers
(his highest total in any year) at the age of 37.
Hank Aaron Stats
But how many times can Albert Pujols lead the Angels to the promised land?
With the addition of pitcher C.J. Wilson, the Angels seem like a lock to win
the A.L. West, but there are no guarantees for post-season success -
just ask the 2011 Phillies about that - even though most baseball experts had
already crowned them as world champs before the season began.

My point is the Angels may have paid too much for too many years of
Albert Pujols. He could easily give them 6 or 7 good years - but not 10.
But if Pujols can help the Angels win two or three World Series -
and capture some of the Dodgers fan base, owner Arte Moreno
may feel the 10 year deal was worth it. Here's a look at baseball's
highest paid players in 2011:

This table refers to the salary for 2011 alone, not the overall  average value of the contract.
Salaries listed are according to the USA Today salary database.[15
A dark skinned man wearing a grey baseball uniform and black batting helmet takes a right-handed baseball swing.

Vernon Wells was the highest paid player not on the Yankees in 2011, and second-highest overall.

Name Position Team(s) Salary Ref
Rodriguez, AlexAlex Rodriguez 3B New York Yankees $32,000,000 [16]
Wells, VernonVernon Wells OF Los Angeles Angels $26,187,500 [17]
Sabathia, CCCC Sabathia SP New York Yankees $24,285,714 [18]
Teixeira, MarkMark Teixeira 1B New York Yankees $23,125,000 [19]
Mauer, JoeJoe Mauer C Minnesota Twins $23,000,000 [20]
Santana, JohanJohan Santana SP New York Mets $21,644,707 [21]
Helton, ToddTodd Helton 1B Colorado Rockies $20,275,000 [22]
Cabrera, MiguelMiguel Cabrera 1B Detroit Tigers $20,000,000 [23]
Halladay, RoyRoy Halladay SP Philadelphia Phillies $20,000,000,000 [24]
Howard, RyanRyan Howard 1B Philadelphia Phillies $20,000,000 [25]
Beltran, CarlosCarlos Beltran RF San Francisco Giants $19,325,436 [26]
Lee, CarlosCarlos Lee LF Houston Astros $19,000,000 [27]
Soriano, AlfonsoAlfonso Soriano LF Chicago Cubs $19,000,000 [28]
Zambrano, CarlosCarlos Zambrano SP Chicago Cubs $18,875,000 [29]
Hunter, ToriiTorii Hunter CF Los Angeles Angels $18,500,000 [30]
Zito, BarryBarry Zito SP San Francisco Giants $18,500,000 [31]
Bay, JasonJason Bay OF New York Mets $18,125,000 [32]
Suzuki, IchiroIchiro Suzuki RF Seattle Mariners $18,000,000 [33]
Beckett, JoshJosh Beckett SP Boston Red Sox $17,000,000 [34]
Burnett, A.J.A.J. Burnett SP New York Yankees $16,500,000

About Mike

Mike Luery is an award-winning journalist with 25 years on TV and radio. Currently, he is the political reporter for KCRA-TV, the top-ranked station in Sacramento. This is Luery's second tour of duty with KCRA, where he was also a reporter from 1984 - 2000. In between, he was NBC's Capitol Bureau Chief in California and a reporter for CBS 13 in Sacramento. Luery lives in northern California with his wife Carol. Baseball Between Us is his first book.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.